Saturday, June 27, 2009

Feminism: An answer to my anonymous critic...



Wow! I certainly got somebody mad with my Feminism post.

I'd love to take a second and address that person personally.... but, I can't because they left the comment anonymously. (!!)

Really, I appreciate the feedback, and I think you brought up some really good points that made me reconsider some of what I said, but how annoying is an anonymous comment? As they say, be a man about it, and show your face!

Hehehe.

That being said, I feel the need to run over a few of the finer points of that post and the reaction to it (especially since many of my closest friends have reacted in a way that makes me feel like I've kicked their elderly grandmother in the spleen or something).

1) I would like the record to show that I am still, and always will consider myself, a feminist. I think it's important for women to assert themselves and their value. What I was trying to convey in that last post, however, was that in the last few years (of married life and motherhood), the notion of feminism has taken on unexpected nuances. That was my point in bringing up the Peggy Orenstein article-- because she is a die-hard, bra-burning, march-to- smash-the-glass-ceiling feminist, but her new role as mother to a girl who likes Princess stuff has led her to reconsider (or at least consider) some of her positions. I feel the same way. For example, now instead of gut reacting against gender roles, I find that occasionally Adam and I slip into them, and it works, and no one is oppressed, and that's fine. This realization is not meant to denigrate the struggle of all the women who have come before me, but one that makes me wonder about the new face of feminism....and how it plays out in individual lives....



2) Regarding mothers, stay-at-home or working: my anonymous critic has rightfully pointed out that envy is not good for anyone. And, I wholeheartedly agree. I got a little carried away in that last post, so forgive the touch of hyperbole. Envy is a destructive emotion and I try to have as little of it as possible in my life. Also, following the above speculations on the individual, daily face of feminism, I absolutely concede that it is ridiculous to try to make normative judgements about mothers...so, for that I apologize...

3) Regarding daycare/childcare/somebody else raising your kids: Again, the mysterious critic makes a good point in saying that daycare is a necessity for some people and also that the parents are actually raising their child (ren) thorough guidance, love, boundaries, etc.

Did I mention that I get a bit melodramatic/hyperbolic sometimes? Can I admit that for the longest time I thought every fight with Adam meant a total breakup? Ok, so now you know that about me....keeping that in mind, then know that my comments were not intended as judgement about those of you who put your kids in daycare. I am just really struggling with letting Liam go. And of course I also struggle with the desire to let him socialize in daycare-- which I think would be really good for him-- versus my crazy inability to trust other people with my child. Is daycare a good thing? I don't know. I know a lot of kids who love it, and also a lot of kids who were traumatized by it. All this may be a moot point, as money issues may drive me to work another job and-- you guessed it-- that means daycare for Liam.

4) Regarding abortion: Oh boy! What a can of worms Jamie opened up here! Again, can I say that by me asserting a position on when life begins, this does not mean that:

a) I'm suddenly a Republican
b) That I think victims of rape automatically should have to raise the babies
c) That I'm betraying my liberal ideas
d) Or that I'm a fan of legislating women's bodies. Again, see my thoughts on how this becomes a real pickle that can lead to control of women's bodies in many Muslim countries.

What I did say, all social issues of what to do with pregnant women or unwanted babies aside , is that I think a baby-in-utero is a baby. It is an actual living little person. Not a parasite. Not a glob of cells. But a little life. Therefore, however it shakes out, I think that abortion is an issue about 2 bodies, not just one.

Is that really such a radical statement? Is its logic dastardly? Does it mean that I am off now to murder abortion doctors and stand on street corners shoving gory posters in the face of rape victims?

No. For fu*#'s sake. Really?

But, it does mean that I think abortion kills a baby. So, sure, that's the mother's right to choose. But, I think that's what she's choosing.

Ok, so there you have it, those are my answers to the anonymous post.

Looking forward to all your comments!

3 comments:

  1. I think that good points are made all around (mostly, that is). I would like to throw in my two cents:

    1. What is the law and what is right can be mutually exclusive. Even old St. Augustine (the first one) said that temporal law (humanity's law) and diviine law (what is right and wrong) are not, can not, and, in many cases, should not be the same.

    2. Every society makes laws that directly impact the rights, permissible actions, and, yes, BODIES of the citizenry. Suicide is illegal. Why aren't the LAWS-OFF-MY-BODY! interlocutors decrying this? Do these people know why suicide is illegal? If not, they should look it up and partipate in the debate when they are more informed.

    3. Jamie's posts in no place advocate a repeal of Roe vs. Wade, so vituperative comments that are predicated upon the idea that she is, in fact, advocating such a repeal, are misplaced. Again, in a debate, one should pay attention to what is actually said, instead of incautiously, ungraciously, and illegitamately ranting.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I had so much to say related to this post that it turned into a whole new blog post over at http://lovelettertomykids.blogspot.com/2009/06/feminism-part-1-if-it-feels-good-do-it.html.

    You can let me know if you think I've completely missed the point, or if I ridiculously, absurdly don't get it. :)

    ReplyDelete